Comparison of New Era InfusionONE and SyringeONE

Comparison of New Era InfusionONE and SyringeONE

The syringe pump is an adjustable device generating a flow rate by volume displacement of liquid in the syringe body. The flow rate is calculated according to the section and the speed of the piston movement Q=S_{piston}\times \nu _{piston}.

The pressure applied to the assembly is not controlled and depends on its fluidic resistance. It can reach high values (>100 bar) for small volume syringes, high flow rate, or high fluid resistance assembly (viscous liquids and small channel dimensions).

With a syringe pump, the stabilization time can be long. This may be caused by the compliance of the walls of the syringe used, and to a lesser extent, by the type of tubing used.

Photography of the red InfusionONE Syringe pump
Photography of the red SyringeONE Syringe pump

Figure 1: (A) The InfusionONE Syringe pump NE-300 and (B) The SyringeONE Syringe pump NE-1000 from New Era

Features of NE-300 and NE-1000 New Era syringe pumps

The InfusionONE Syringe pump NE-300 from New Era

The InfusionONE 1-way syringe pump is easy to use with a 3-step operation. Unit, speed, and direction of flow are user-programmable.

  • Syringe volume: up to 60 mL
  • Syringe inside diameter range: from 0.100 to 50 mm
  • Flow range: from 0.73 µl/hr to 1500 ml/hr
  • Flow accuracy: +/- 1 %

The SyringeONE Syringe pump NE-1000 from New Era

The SyringeONE pump is fully programmable standalone or through a computer. According to the user’s needs, the SyringeONE is available in different versions depending on the number of channels and linear force. We will focus here on the standard version (NE-2000).

  • Syringe volume: up to 140 mL
  • Flow range: from 8 pL/h to 1961 mL/min
  • Flow accuracy: +/- 1%

Flow accuracy measurement tests

For our tests, we chose to compare two New Era syringe pumps: the NE-300 and the NE-1000. The New Era Pump Systems series of syringe pumps are a cost-effective solution to dispense a precise control of fluid. Our aim here is to compare the accuracy with which the two syringe pumps deliver the flow from a set value of flow rate (from 50 to 500 µl/min). A syringe of 2.5 mL is used on each syringe pump, the accuracy is measured using the Elveflow MFS4 flow sensor.

Flow-rate stability graph of the syringeONE and the infusionONE at 50ul/min

At low flow rates, the two syringe pumps seem to have the same sensitivity, especially after a stabilisation period of about 4 seconds. Overall, at 50 µl/min, both syringe pumps deliver flow rates 5% higher than the set value.

Flow-rate stability graph of the syringeONE and the infusionONE at 100ul/min

For an intermediate value of 100 µl/min, the NE-1000 seems more appropriate as it has a flow profile that is generally less than 2% deviation from the value of 100 µl/min.

Flow-rate stability graph of the syringeONE and the infusionONE at 500ul/min

Finally, for high values, the NE-1000 syringe pump remains the most accurate instrument in terms of flow rate with an overall deviation profile of less than 2%.

Obviously, the choice of the instrument and its accuracy will depend on your application. New Era syringe pumps are robust and high-performance instruments, with an excellent price/performance ratio.